Why We Use Animal Fat

Short answer: tallow is not vegan, and we are not going to argue otherwise. What we will argue is that the choice is more complicated than animal versus plant. Tallow is a byproduct of an existing cattle industry, sourced from fat that would otherwise be discarded. The main plant alternative, palm oil, carries its own well-documented environmental cost. If you are vegan, tallow is not for you, and that is a legitimate position. If your concern is environmental rather than ethical, the comparison is worth actually making.

Most tallow brands avoid this topic. We would rather answer it directly.

If you are vegan, this is where the conversation ends

Tallow comes from cattle. There is no version of that fact that accommodates a vegan ethic, and pretending otherwise would be insulting.

We are not going to try to talk anyone out of a position they arrived at deliberately. Squalane, shea, and jojoba are all real options and there are brands making good products with them. Go buy from those brands with our blessing.

The rest of this is for people whose objection is environmental or intuitive rather than ethical, because that is a different question with a genuinely different answer.

The byproduct argument, stated honestly

Cattle are not raised for tallow. They are raised for beef. Suet, the hard fat around the kidneys that makes the best tallow, is a small fraction of the animal, and historically much of it was rendered for candles and soap or simply discarded.

So the honest framing is this: choosing tallow does not create demand for another animal. It uses part of one that was already going to market, and it uses a part that frequently goes to waste. Advocates for regenerative agriculture describe this as closing the loop, and it is a fair description of the material flow.

What it is not is a moral wash. The cattle industry exists with or without your face oil, and if you object to that industry existing, using its offcuts does not resolve the objection. It just means you are not adding to it.

The plant comparison people skip

The unstated assumption in "plant-based is better" is that the plant alternative is neutral. Often it is not.

Palm oil and its derivatives are the workhorse of natural skincare, appearing in emulsifiers, stearic acid, cetyl alcohol, and dozens of ingredients whose names give no hint of their origin. Palm cultivation has driven substantial deforestation in Southeast Asia with well-documented effects on habitat and carbon emissions. Certification schemes exist and help, and traceability through the supply chain remains genuinely difficult.

Shea and cocoa butter come with their own supply chain questions around labor and land use. Almond and avocado are water intensive in regions already under water stress.

None of that makes plant oils bad. It makes them a tradeoff rather than an absence of one, which is the part usually left out of the comparison.

Why we would use it even if the ethics were neutral

There is a functional reason too, and it is the reason tallow came back at all.

Tallow's fatty acid profile closely resembles the lipids human skin produces. That biocompatibility is why it absorbs rather than sitting on the surface, and why it suits dry, sensitive, and barrier-compromised skin so well. It also carries fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K, which is a function of what the animal ate. Grass-fed and pasture-raised tallow has a different profile than conventional.

No plant oil reproduces that composition, because plants do not make the same fats mammals do. Some come close on individual measures. None match the whole profile. We compared them directly in tallow vs plant oils and ceramides.

What we actually control

Sourcing is where a brand's position on this becomes real or stays rhetorical.

Ours is grass-fed and pasture-raised, sourced from farms we know rather than a commodity broker. We render by hand, in small batches, at low heat. Our ingredient lists run to eight items, not thirty.

That does not make the underlying question disappear. It does mean that if you decide tallow is a reasonable choice for you, you can know where this particular tallow came from.

Where ours comes from

Our Gilded Goddess Tallow + Rosehip Body & Face Oil is built on organic grass-fed tallow, rendered by hand in small batches, blended with cold-pressed rosehip oil. Eight ingredients on the label and nothing on it you need a chemistry degree to read.

Shop Gilded Goddess · Browse all face products

The short version

Tallow is not vegan and we will not pretend the question is complicated for someone holding that position. For everyone else, the comparison is between a byproduct of an existing industry and plant oils that carry their own environmental costs, and it is closer than the marketing on either side suggests.

We use tallow because of what it does on skin, and we source it the way we do because if you are going to use an animal product, the sourcing is the part you can actually be responsible for.

These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. This product is not intended to treat, diagnose, cure, or prevent any disease.